Look Back at Henry Cavill's Dating History, From Kaley Cuoco to Current Love Natalie Viscuso

Cavill proposed to the English show jumping rider in 2011 after two years of dating. "I couldn't believe it when he asked me to marry him. I thought we were there to celebrate his birthday," Whitaker told the Belfast Telegraph of Cavill's romantic proposal at the time. "It was such a surprise and I am so happy." However, about a year later in August 2012, it was revealed that the two had privately called it quits months prior. "There was no fallout. They just both agreed it wasn't working," a source told Us Weekly. "They broke up three months ago."