The Bachelor premiered on Jan. 1, but Jimmy Kimmel already has a guess at which lady will steal Arie Luyendyk Jr.'s heart. During Jimmy Kimmel Live on Tuesday, the host grilled the 36-year-old race car driver about who he picks. While Luyendyk didn't budge, he did admit that he fell in love with two women this season. With this tidbit of information, Kimmel predicted that he will actually fall for Bekah M. (who is nearly 15 years his junior) and Becca K. This wouldn't be the first time Kimmel has correctly guessed a winner. Not only did he predict that Nick Viall would pick Vanessa last season, but he also said that JoJo Fletcher would end up Jordan Rodgers on The Bachelorette. Guess we'll just have to wait and see if he's right this time around.