Pretty Little Liars: A Timeline of the Night Ali Disappears

Alison hops from meeting to meeting, threatening, blackmailing, and extorting her way through Rosewood's residents. Her first stop is Toby.

• Toby claims he wants to thank Alison for not releasing the incriminating video of him and Jenna.
• He insists she was very much alive when they parted ways.
• He loans her his sweater because she gets cold.
• She slips off to her next rendezvous with a strange man in a car, still wearing Toby's sweater.