This Scream Queens Baby Theory Has Pretty Much Been Proven

Let's say Grace's mom, a college freshman, was dating a fellow 18-year-old college freshman. That would make the baby's dad 38 years old, and actor Oliver Hudson just turned 39. If Grace is the bathtub baby, it would also explain why he hates sororities so much and doesn't want Grace involved in one.

Also, we're pretty sure that Grace was sheltered by Gigi for a while, so what if Wes isn't even Grace's biological dad? What if he's her adoptive father and never told her about it, or worse — what if he kidnapped her?