8 American Horror Story Characters Who Have Appeared on More Than 1 Season

Seasons: Asylum, Freak Show

Sister Mary Eunice (Lily Rabe) crosses between seasons as a direct result of Pepper's crossover. When Pepper's sister goes to Briarcliff to admit Pepper for the murder of her baby, Sister Mary Eunice is the one behind the desk filling out the paperwork. Though she later becomes possessed by the devil on Freak Show, the Sister begins as a sympathetic character, giving Pepper a job in the library once she is a patient.