8 American Horror Story Characters Who Have Appeared on More Than 1 Season

Seasons: Murder House, Hotel

We first meet Charles Montgomery (Matt Ross) in the pilot season, and though we knew the Murder House would be revisited during Hotel, we didn't anticipate that Charles would reappear. The Countess, supposedly "three weeks" along, visits him to get an abortion. He attempts it, but her baby is born — and it's a monster.