The Most Bizarre American Horror Story Theories Out There

They're both handsome, dapper, charming, completely psychopathic, and homicidal. It's not too much of a stretch to think they could be related. A Redditor connected Dandy and Oliver, suggesting they have the same mother, Gloria, especially since she talks about killing running in the family in Freak Show. Then, Gloria gave up the evil doctor for adoption right after he was born. Oliver Thredson spent his young life in an orphanage, and that's probably where he picked up the last name. Since we don't know much about their father, maybe he is a murderous villain too.