19 Times This Is Us Made Us Bawl Like a Baby

The Pearson family straight-up lied to us when they said nothing bad happens on Christmas. During their holiday get-together, Toby makes amends with Kate by showing up at her doorstep. The two have a happy reunion in the living room, until Toby grabs his chest and collapses on the floor. Oh, and did we mention this was the Winter finale? Thankfully, he makes it through, but boy did that wreck us.

Cry meter: 😭 😭