39 of the Hottest Hookups in Pretty Little Liars History

Dating one of Melissa's beaus clearly isn't enough for Spencer, because she quickly finds herself attached to her sister's fiancé, Wren. The two do some pretty serious flirting — including half-naked massages — before Melissa finds them kissing and ends her engagement. Whenever Wren pops up in later seasons, he and Spencer wind up making out in some poorly lit corner. Like every other character in the show, Wren is suspected of being A, putting an end to #Wrencer.