Murphy pitched this one as a "red, white and blue clue." Many fans in the comments suggested this might be Evan Peters's character, but there's no way of knowing. Here's what we're wondering: is this person working with the scary elephant thing? Is this person wearing the elephant mask? If we have two psychopaths on the loose, it's going to get real.
As a bonus theory, it's interesting that the elephant thing has red lips, and this guy has blue hair. There's got to be some sort of Democrat/Republican symbolism at play here. Just some food for thought.
