Skip Nav
Love It. Save Your Favorites Now.
4 Intriguing Theories You Should Dive Into After Finishing The Keepers
View On One Page
Photo 4 of 4  
ADVERTISEMENT ()
4

Theory: Edgar Killed Someone, but It Wasn't Cathy

Perhaps one of the most disturbing aspects of The Keepers is the interview process with an elderly man named Edgar, who is a suspect in the murders. One Reddit theorist explores why they think he's innocent in the murder of Cathy Cesnik — but guilty of another — in the theory below.

Edgar & the Joyce Malecki case: unanswered (and unasked) questions, and a theory from The_Keepers

Previous Next
r/MomForAMinute Reddit Community Offers Maternal Support
Mother's Day
Meet the Reddit Community That Will Be Your Mom For a Minute
by Taylor Andrews 5/07
Netflix's Age of Attraction Shows Power Imbalances
Netflix
The Real Reason Netflix's "Age of Attraction" Is So Cringe-y
by Angel Martinez 4/09
Beauty Secrets From FX's "Love Story"
Beauty News
Carolyn Bessette's Lipstick and Other Behind-the-Scenes Details From "Love Story"
by Jessica Harrington 3/25
Why Netflix's "Battle Camp" Is Psychologically Appealing
Netflix
We Can't Escape the Allure of Reality Competition Shows
by Korin Miller 4/23/25
"Love on the Spectrum" Siblings Talk Life Before the Show
Autism
The "Love on the Spectrum" Siblings Open Up About Life With Connor, Abbey, and Tanner
by Korin Miller 4/11/25
The Beauty Routines of Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders
Beauty News
How the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Look So Good
by Audrey Noble 6/19/25

From Our Partners

Now You Know

Love Is Blind: Where Do Those Engagement Rings Come From?

Fashion

Everything to Know About the "Love Is Blind" Engagement Rings

by Sarah Wasilak 2/19

shopping

Oprah's Favorite Things List Has Major Gems, Including an Under-$100 Air Fryer

by Balim Tezel 11/06/25

Fitness

Paralympians Earn the Same Pay For Medals as Olympians, but Is It Enough?

by Karenna Meredith 8/29/24

health

How Often Should We Be Getting COVID Vaccines?

by Alexis Jones 8/23/24

Food

Pumpkin Spice Season Is Back Aug. 22

by Lauren Mazzo 8/21/24

Beauty

The Exact Red Lipstick Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Swears By

by Alaina Demopoulos 8/20/24

health

What to Know About the Latest Mpox Outbreak, According to MDs

by Alexis Jones 8/16/24

health

Céline Dion Promised Her Children She’d Live: “They Already Lost a Parent.”

by Sara Youngblood Gregory 6/11/24

Latest Entertainment
We're Hiring! Write For Us Advertise With Us Accessibility Contact Archives
Power Your Happy
Terms Privacy Policy
©2026 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.