7 Characters Who Could Be American Horror Story: Cult's True Leader

Ally's wife is no innocent. She met Winter long before she showed up on her doorstep looking for a babysitting job. Even though Kai was deep in his recruitment phase by the time Winter and Ivy met, Ivy is still a suspect. Her connection to Ally, who seems to be at the center of the conspiracy, makes Ivy complicit in her wife's torment. It also means she may be the person around which Kai wants his group of followers to rally.