This Is Where You've Seen the Hilarious Cast of American Vandal Before

Born and raised in Denver, CO (not too far from Boulder, where Dylan wanted to go to school), Karly Rothenberg started her acting career in 1986 with a TV movie called The Last Frontier. She went on to play Madge in a handful of episodes in The Office, as well as Marlene in the 2011 TV show The Protector. Grey's Anatomy, Bad Teacher, and Superstore have also featured appearances from Rothenberg.