Who's Going to Be the Next Bachelor? We (Probably) Know Him Already

Joe Amabile — aka Grocery Store Joe — sadly left the competition the first night of the season, but he never left our hearts. The sweet grocery store owner became so beloved that he nabbed a spot on Bachelor in Paradise and arrived on the After the Final Rose special to major applause.

"I don't know if Joe would be here if it wasn't for that outpouring of love and support on night one," host Christ Harrison told E! News. "People love the guy and freaked out. People like that, when we see them pop and really become of the American consciousness, then yeah, they become the Bachelor. Nick was a good example of that, you never know when your Bachelor is going to pop out."