The Most Memorable Deaths on American Horror Story: Coven

Every creepy old academy needs a creepy old butler, and Spalding fulfills the role to a tee. Mute, doll-obsessed, and with a stalker-ish crush on Fiona, he's nothing if not loyal to Fiona. When Madison is murdered and her body is found among his "dolls," the other girls interrogate him. Zoe returns his tongue to him and magically compels him to tell the truth, and when he admits Fiona was behind the murder, Zoe stabs him to death.