In this flick, scream queen Anya Taylor-Joy plays Thomasin, a young woman who witnesses the disappearance of her youngest brother in 1630 New England and is consequently accused of witchcraft. Taylor-Joy plays Thomasin with such conviction that you actually believe she's trapped in a 17th-century waking nightmare, though her frightfully good performance is only matched by Black Phillip, who might even have the demonic humanoid goat who plays Satan in Chilling Adventures of Sabrina beat for the scariest goat of all time.
Where to watch: Amazon Prime
