12 Iconic American Idol Auditions That Still Send Shivers Down Our Spines

Ask longtime Underwood fans when they knew she was the real deal, and most of them will point to this moment. In her very first audition, singing "I Can't Make You Love Me," we got our first glimpse of Underwood's genuine personality and the pure, heartfelt voice that would take her from Idol champion to full-fledged music superstar.