Colton has gone on and on about how much he wants a girl who's there "for the right reasons" and who will be ready to get engaged at the end of the season, which made his decision to keep Cassie instead of Caelynn rather interesting. Caelynn professed her love for him and her father gave Colton permission for her hand in marriage, while Cassie couldn't bring herself to say those three little words or convince her own dad that the connection she shares with Colton is legit.
At the end of the hometown date episode, Colton still went with Cassie, sending Caelynn packing. If we had to guess, Colton is clearly head over heels for this girl, right? Otherwise it really wouldn't make sense to keep her around since she's the riskier choice in terms of who can guarantee a "yes" to his proposal.
