Fans Think They Know Who the Dad Is After "How I Met Your Father"'s Cancellation

Sid has always ranked pretty low on the list of possible fathers, but only because he's married to Hannah. But at the end of season two, Sid found out Hannah cheated on him, and it looks like they could be breaking up for good.

Sid and Sophie probably interact the least out of the main cast, but some fans are convinced that's just to keep viewers off the scent. Plus, it's hard to imagine a future where Jesse would be totally fine with his bestie being with Sophie. Yet, seen from another perspective, that gives Sophie and Sid the most interesting dramatic odds to get through. If the show had been renewed (or returned on another streamer), it could be interesting to see how the show tried to pull it off.