17 of Evan Peters's Best Movie and TV Roles, From "Kick-Ass" to "American Horror Story"

Peters continued his "AHS" streak with the fourth season, set in a 1950s "freak show" in Florida. He plays Jimmy, a young man who is part of the troupe due to a genetic condition that fuses his fingers together to resemble "claws." He's particularly protective of a pair of conjoined twins, Bette and Dot, and he soon finds himself in the middle of a tangled web of blackmail, con artists, and frame-ups for murder.