We Finally Know Everyone's Relative on "Claim to Fame"

Cole claims during two truths and a lie that his celebrity is his father. For his talent, he spray-paints. During the episode four challenge, we get one more clue for Cole: a block of swiss cheese. Monay hints that she and Shayne have figured out even more about his relative without him knowing.

In episode five, we find out Monay has put together that Cole is related to Alicia Keys. On the clue wall, there's a piano, sheet music, and a diary; in 2003, Keys released "The Diary of Alicia Keys." The limerick during the challenge also has a reference to keys. During the guessing, Karsyn correctly guesses Alicia is Cole's sister. He calls her "my rock and my best friend."