Karsyn says during two truths and a lie that her relative is a musician. During the talent show, she does a horrible rendition of "Amazing Grace," but it's not clear if it's a tactic to keep others off her trail.
Shayne pulls Karsyn's big clue, and it has a trophy, an eraser, a minus sign, a question mark, two records, and four beers. In episode four, the cast becomes convinced that this clue points to NASCAR driver Jeff Gordon. During the episode's challenge, we also find out that a tire is a clue for her person. But Karsyn tells Chris that Gordon is not her celebrity, which sows enough doubt to keep her safe.
The contestants use the episode six challenge to probe Karsyn for info about her relative and to try to prove it's Gordon. But when Karsyn guesses the race car driver, we learn that Olivia has successfully misled them all, and she's not related to him.
In episode seven, the contestants learn her relative has won Daytona multiple times in a row and is associated with Danica Patrick, Mark Zuckerberg, and JAY-Z. Karsyn is Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s niece. In episode nine, Chris guesses this correctly, and Karsyn is eliminated.
