The Best Healthy Ice Creams We've Tried So Far

Protein-packed ice cream from ProYo won our office over with flavors like coconut and mint chip that totally delivered a high-quality taste with a whole lot of nutrition.

We kind of lost our minds when we found out that Ben & Jerry's was making dairy-free flavors — the Coconut Seven Layer Bar is so good, we felt like it wasn't even real. Make sure you look for these with the other dairy-free options (not with the rest of the Ben & Jerry's flavors!) in the frozen section.

We didn't think it was possible for something so decadent as gelato to have a healthy variety, but Forte Gelato proved us and our colleagues wrong when it blew us away with creamy and delicious flavors and perfectly portioned cups.

The best part about Enlightened healthy ice cream is probably the fact that "butter pecan" and "100 calories" can be printed on the same label — and it's not false advertising.

Halo Top stole our hearts from the very first bite, and when the brand came out with fantastic new flavors (hello, cookie dough), it was cemented in our hearts — and our bellies — as the crown jewel of healthy ice creams. It's hard for us to leave the grocery store without picking up a pint of this heavenly goodness.

Arctic Zero is definitely one of the lower-calorie options (though lacking in the protein department) and is lactose-free, meaning you can still have ice cream even if you're lactose intolerant. Your best bet (according to our taste testers): get banana pudding or brownie blast.

This frozen Yasso Greek Yogurt was so good, our samples disappeared within moments of offering them to our colleagues for a taste test. The vanilla sandwiches were a crowd favorite, but the pops didn't disappoint either.