Bring On the Butterbeer! These Harry Potter Recipes Will Inspire an Enchanting Party

We all know Harry Potter fans can't get enough of the wizarding world, and thanks to these sweet and savory recipes, they'll have a taste of it. Though it may be difficult (or, er, impossible) for us measly muggles to re-create spells, one thing we can bring to life is the food and drink mentioned in the books. From tasty renditions of the books' famous butterbeer to sweet, golden snitch-inspired recipes and even a savory, cherry-studded ham for dinner, your family and friends will be beyond impressed by your wizard-like abilities. Though it may not be as easy as shouting "Accio butterbeer!", these recipes are absolutely doable for the home cook.

— Additional reporting by Anna Monette Roberts

01
The Golden Snitch Cocktail
Half Baked Harvest

The Golden Snitch Cocktail

Influenced with Harry Potter's golden snitch, this bubbly drink is made with sweet apple cider, whiskey, St. Germain, lemon, maple, and a few spices. Rim it with cinnamon sugar and you have the perfect cocktail to sip while reading the series (for the 100th time).

02
Mrs. Weasley's Chocolate Fudge
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Mrs. Weasley's Chocolate Fudge

Make a batch of chocolate fudge and sprinkle some edible gold stars on top for a touch of magic.

03
Forbidden Forest Cake
Half Baked Harvest

Forbidden Forest Cake

Chocolate-lovers and Harry Potter fans alike will be in awe of this cake. Made of three chocolate layers, chocolate butterbeer frosting, weeping willow chocolate trees, pretzel spiders, and completed with a marshmallow spider web, the dessert is straight out of Harry Potter's forbidden forest.

04
Harry Potter Dark Magic Macarons
Delaney Dobson Photography

Harry Potter Dark Magic Macarons

Use black food coloring to transform french macarons into a dessert fit for a Slytherin. Paint on Harry Potter symbols like a lightening bolt and 9 3/4 with edible gold paint for a final festive touch.

05
The Deathly Hallows Cocktail
Half Baked Harvest

The Deathly Hallows Cocktail

Become "the master of death" with the deathly hallows cocktail. Made of cranberry juice, Mezcal, orange liqueur, lemon juice, maple, and ginger beer, this cocktail is a breeze to sip on.

06
Harry Potter Decorative Sugar Cookies
Delaney Dobson Photography

Harry Potter Decorative Sugar Cookies

Give iced sugar cookies a magical upgrade with owl, broom, and triangle cookie cutters.

07
Death by Butterbeer Cupcakes
Half Baked Harvest

Death by Butterbeer Cupcakes

If you want a treat that'll make your mouth water, these death by butterbeer cupcakes do it. Drizzled with butterscotch mixed with butter extract to replicate Harry Potter's notorious butterbeer, the glaze in itself could be a dessert. Top off the cupcakes with chocolate frosting and dipped chocolate pretzels, and you're ready to eat!

08
Pumpkin Pasties
Getty | Paperboat

Pumpkin Pasties

Available on the Hogwarts Express and at Honeydukes, pumpkin pasties are essentially pocket pies stuffed with a savory pumpkin filling.

09
Pumpkin Butterbeer Hot Chocolate
Half Baked Harvest

Pumpkin Butterbeer Hot Chocolate

Make butterbeer THAT much better with this creamy pumpkin butterbeer hot chocolate recipe. The secret ingredient is milk chocolate, and it tastes delicious with whipped cream and butterscotch drizzled on top.

10
Flaming Christmas Pudding
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Flaming Christmas Pudding

If you're looking to re-create the Hogwarts Christmas feast from Harry Potter and brave enough to try something a little on the complex side, try this flaming Christmas pudding.

11
Harry Potter-Inspired Pumpkin Juice
Half Baked Harvest

Harry Potter-Inspired Pumpkin Juice

There are many occasions in the Harry Potter series where pumpkin juice is mentioned, and now, the recipe can be brought into your own home! Feel like a true wizard drinking this cozy, autumnal drink.

12
Butterbeer Ice Cream
The Farmers Daughter

Butterbeer Ice Cream

Ice cream and butterbeer? It's total deliciousness in a cup and great to enjoy throughout every season. Made of butterscotch, browned butter, cream soda, and more, you'll be in heaven enjoying this dessert.

13
Butterbeer Cookies
Cookies and Cups

Butterbeer Cookies

If you haven't noticed, there are a slew of ways to incorporate butterbeer into your baking, and these butterbeer cookies top the charts. Not only are they simple to make, but their buttery base melts in your mouth. Finished with creamy butterscotch ganache, you can't go wrong with this yummy sweet.

14
The Half-Blood Prince Cocktail
Half Baked Harvest

The Half-Blood Prince Cocktail

Inspired by the Harry Potter series, this blood-red cocktail consists of pomegranate, bourbon, Chambord, and lemon. The drink is devilishly delicious, and makes for quite a spooky sight.

15
Pumpkin Pastries
Whitney Bond

Pumpkin Pastries

Young wizards loved eating pumpkin pastries aboard the Hogwarts Express, and now you can eat them in your own home. The treat can be made both savory or sweet, but sweet is what this recipe calls for. Filled with a pumpkin cream cheese mix, these flavorful pastries can be served for breakfast, brunch, or dessert.

16
The Death Eater Negroni
Half Baked Harvest

The Death Eater Negroni

Muggles, watch out! The death eater negroni is not meant for those without magical powers. However, if you want to test your chances, it sounds very good. Made with gin, Campari, sweet vermouth, and pomegranate juice, this negroni is lip-smacking good.

17
Cauldron Cupcakes
Cookies and Cups

Cauldron Cupcakes

Yet another food found on the Hogwarts Express food trolley, these cupcakes are made with a red velvet base. Coated with vanilla buttercream frosting that's topped with mini peanut butter cups dabbed with green frosting on top (to look like a cauldron), these cauldron cupcakes are both easy and fun to make!

18
Steak and Kidney Pie
The Curious Coconut

Steak and Kidney Pie

Served at many Hogwarts feasts, this steak and kidney pie recipe is a delicious British entrée! Made with grass-fed beef kidney and a flavorful crust, this savory pie is a great meal to eat during cold months.

19
Butterbeer
Cooking Classy

Butterbeer

As we know, butterbeer isn't a real-life drink (sorry, Potterheads!), so every recipe of the drink calls for something different! This one, in particular, isn't too sweet or rich, making it easy to slug down.

20
Leaky Cauldron Pea Soup
POPSUGAR Photography | Erin Cullum

Leaky Cauldron Pea Soup

Ready for a pea soup that's definitely not your grandma's and that would turn Harry Potter into a Leaky Cauldron regular? Accio slow cooker!

21
Golden Snitch Chocolates
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Golden Snitch Chocolates

There may only be one golden snitch in Harry Potter's world, but you can make endless golden snitch chocolates for your next Harry Potter-themed party using this easy and tasty DIY. No cooking or baking required!

22
Licorice Wands
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Licorice Wands

Sprinkles, white chocolate, and a fruit rope is all you need to re-create these Honeydukes licorice wands.

23
Cherry-Studded Ham
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Cherry-Studded Ham

During Hogwarts' annual holiday event, students would feast on a cherry-studded ham, and now, you can too. Prep and roast this ham for a large dinner —everyone will be in awe of its scrumptious flavor.

24
Mrs. Weasley's Ugly Christmas Sweater Cookies
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Mrs. Weasley's Ugly Christmas Sweater Cookies

Entertain guests by piping their initials on Mrs. Weasley's ugly Christmas sweater cookies, they'll love the personal touch.

25
Butterbeer Latte
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Butterbeer Latte

Combine butterbeer and a pumpkin spice latte and what do you get? The butterbeer latte. Both tasty and sweet, this recipe is so easy, you'll hardly have to lift a finger.

26
Butterbeer
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Butterbeer

Hot or cold, butterbeer, made with real butter and beer, is a staple to take the edge off.

27
Pumpkin Juice
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Pumpkin Juice

Muggles drink OJ, but wizards subsist off of pumpkin juice morning, noon, and night.

29
Firewhisky
POPSUGAR Photography

Firewhisky

Ogden's Old Firewhisky and Blishen's Firewhisky are a few popular brands of the alcohol said to create a burning sensation while consumed and to inspire courage. While it's not entirely known what's in it, we imagine it to be like homemade Fireball, a combination of whiskey, cinnamon, and spicy chilis.

30
Rock Cake
POPSUGAR Photography | Anna Monette Roberts

Rock Cake

A type of fruitcake with a crunchy exterior served with tea, rock cake takes on a literal meaning when Hagrid makes them. His batches are usually so overcooked that they nearly break teeth when chewed. Though this confection has earned a terrible reputation, when made correctly (and served with blue cheese as is traditional in England), rock cake may earn a place in your heart.

31
Pin It!

Pin It!