Pick Up: Cultured Salted Butter ($3)
If you've never tried cultured butter, it has a slightly tart flavor and richer mouthfeel than standard butter. When we dove our knives into this, our first thought was, better than Kerrygold (one of our favorite Irish butters)? Not quite, but pretty darn close. We will stock up on this slightly salty butter from TJ's, no problem.