Every Harry Potter Fan Should Complete This Incredible, Edible Bucket List

Butterbeer soft-serve is the most coveted treat to order at Florean Fortescue's Ice Cream Parlour — albeit not part of the book series. It tastes exactly like butterscotch ice cream and the dreamy soft-serve you used to eat as a kid. Chocolate chili is another favorite that has a nice kick to it!

If you want to do something authentic to the book series, you can order what Harry eats every day in the Summer before his third year at Hogwarts: strawberry and peanut butter (blended together in one flavor). According to POPSUGAR editors who've tried it, it's strange and for adventure-seekers.

Where to find it: Diagon Alley, across from Ollivander's, and the Three Broomsticks in Hogsmeade