We were absolutely skeptical of Peeps Oreos when they were released ahead of Easter. But the pink-colored icing and golden cookie left us pleasantly surprised — we even went back for seconds! There's no marshmallow in the cream filling, but it does have the quintessential sugar crystals that coat the exterior of Peeps, giving each bite a slightly gritty texture. Peeps Oreos are not overly sweet as we'd anticipated and even reminded us of one of our favorite nostalgic cereals: Lucky Charms.
There's only a teeny bit of a problem. Soon after the product's release, many people began claiming that Peeps Oreos turned their . . . poop pink. We can personally vouch that the artificially dyed icing did in fact stain our tongues slightly, but we imagine you'd have to eat nearly an entire package to allow the side effects to go that far.
