Skip Nav
Decorating Tips
The 3 Most Important Decorating Elements, According to a Designer
House Tour
This 200-Square-Foot Tiny House Is as Luxurious as a Mansion
Cheap Area Rug
Living Rooms
The $80 Area Rug That Made Me Forget I Hate My Ugly Brown Carpet

Couple Sues HGTV's Love It or List it

One Couple's Nightmare Renovation on Love It or List It Is Turning Into a Lawsuit

A post shared by Hilary Farr (@hilary_farr) on

We all can't get enough of David and Hilary from HGTV's Love It or List It, but one couple from North Carolina was more than dissatisfied with their own renovation on the beloved show. Deena Murphy and Timothy Sullivan even went as far as suing the show's production company, Big Coat Productions, claiming they were "victims of shoddy work and unfair trade practices," according to Today.

Although the two seemed happy with the results during the big reveal in their episode and listed property, much damage was apparently done to their home. Low-grade carpet was installed, their floors were ruined, and their windows were "painted shut." Of the $140,000 Deena and Timothy put in for their home's makeover, $85,000 was given to the contractor, and the couple believes that the remaining amount was put toward "the production of its series." The couple's lawsuit further states how the television show has priority over the interests of the homeowners, but Big Coat says "this claim is in no way supported by any of the facts of the case."

While it's disheartening to hear that the show may not be all that it seems, it's yet to be decided whether the couple's allegations hold true.

From Our Partners
15 Things You Didn't Know About the Third Scott Brother
Fixer Upper Decorating Inspiration
Fixer Upper: Behind the Design Show Details
How to Get Cast on Fixer Upper
Best Pieces From the Novogratz
The 1 Big Reason Some Fans Are Saying Property Brothers Is Fake
When Is Joanna Gaines Due With Baby Number 5?
Joanna Gaines's Tips For Organizing a Laundry Room
Chip and Joanna Gaines Food Facts
Bathroom Updates For Resale
Joanna Gaines's Favorite Paint Colors
What Happens to Giant House Poster on Fixer Upper
From Our Partners
Latest Home & Garden
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds