Saatva is the oldest mail-order mattress company on this list — and the most expensive. It was founded by mattress technology experts and furniture executives in 2010 and has its headquarters in Westport, CT. Unlike Casper and Leesa, Saatva comes in three firmness options: Luxury Firm, Firm, and Plush Soft. It is also the only mattress on this list with coils.
Verdict: Most customers seem not to mind the higher price tag, and they report feeling better rested than with other mattresses. Its flagship mattress is the Luxury Firm, and it seems to be the preferred option — even for people who tried the Firm and Plush Soft options. Other reviewers like the good customer service, full-service home delivery, and high-quality materials.
Cost: $599 (twin) to $1,299 (California king)
Trial Period: 75 days
Warranty: 15 years
