Kaitlyn's Most Loved, Hated, and Bizarre Bachelors

Tanner emerged from obscurity by charming us with jokes about said obscurity, including this winning rhyme at Kaitlyn's Irish wake: "I like you and want time tonight, so put it in your planner, and in case you forgot, my name is Tanner." I did forget you at one point, Tanner, but I'll definitely wave from my couch when I spot you on stage!