What Fenty Beauty's New Holiday Lipsticks Actually Look Like on 4 Women

When blessed with a package of Fenty Beauty's holiday collection before it hits stores on Oct. 13, you don't just let it sit around and look pretty. Nope, you play. A lot. And that's what we've been doing all day. After testing out the new Cosmic Lip Gloss, we just had to see what the new lipsticks — Rihanna's first ones! — looked like in real life, too.

These holographic-looking tubes are foolproof. They feel like a balm and go on sheer at first, but you can build them up and get a more intense color ready for the party circuit. They have a shimmery finish that's layerable over other lip shades you love. And, although there are metallic glitter particles, you don't feel any grain on your pout.

Ahead, find out even more details on the newest additions to the Fenty family, and get a closer look at both swatches and the shades worn by four women.

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in $upanova

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in $upanova

The Shade: Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in $upanova (twinkling pink orchid), $19

The Review: "The moment I slicked on this fun and glittery lipstick, my first thought was: Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century. Though it's a girlier shade I might not typically wear, the creamy texture and glossy effect really won me over. The packaging also kills it." — Kelsey Garcia, assistant trending editor

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Supermoon

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Supermoon

The Shade: Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Supermoon (sparkling peach), $19

The Review: "This is my first time trying a Fenty product (I know, I'm late!) and after putting Starlit on my lips, I'm a fan. I wasn't wearing any makeup on this day, not even ChapStick, and the lipstick looked completely natural on my face. It glided seamlessly across my lips and didn't leave weird smudge marks. The color looks peachy pink in the tube, but upon application, it shimmers in the light. The lipstick's a great option for everyday wear if you want a pop of color." — Marina Liao, assistant fashion editor

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Sci-Fly

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Sci-Fly

The Shade: Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Sci-Fly (glimmering garnet), $19

The Review: "This lipstick is superversatile because it appears like a dark berry color in some lights but in others, it looks like a dark wine color. It's full of glitter, but you don't feel it on the lips one bit. It's the perfect lip to rock from day to night." — Celia Fernandez, assistant POPSUGAR Latina editor

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Gravity

Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Gravity

The Shade: Fenty Beauty Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick in Gravity (shimmering hot pink), $19

The Review: "This is definitely a party lip. You can feel the glitter as you apply it, but once it's on, it's a comfortable wear. The color is really fun and could easily add some sparkle to any holiday outfit." — Madison Metlzer, associate social media strategist

Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick Swatches

Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick Swatches

Top to bottom: Sci-Fly (glimmering garnet), $upanova (twinkling pink orchid), Gravity (shimmering hot pink), and Supermoon (sparkling peach).

Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick

Starlit Hyper-Glitz Lipstick

Left to right: Sci-Fly (glimmering garnet), Supermoon (sparkling peach), Gravity (shimmering hot pink), and $upanova (twinkling pink orchid).