Skip Nav
21 New Books Your Friends Are Going to Be Talking About This September
Joaquin Phoenix as the Joker Video
Joaquin Phoenix
Another Creepy Look at Joaquin Phoenix as the Joker — and This Time, He's All Made Up
Joaquin Phoenix
Everything You Need to Know About the Joker Movie
Award Season
Um, Quincy Jones Has an Unbelievable Number of Grammys
Grey's Anatomy Season 15 Love Triangle Details
Grey's Anatomy
Grey's Anatomy Stars Tease Season 15's Refreshing Take on the Love Triangle

Where Do the Characters in This Is Us Live?

Wait, What? This Plot Hole in This Is Us Is Pretty Darn Confusing


This Is Us does a really good job switching between the past and the present in each of its storylines, which can't be an easy task for the show's writers. But one fan has pointed out a tiny detail that will make you pause for a minute and think, "Wait, what?!" This potential plot hole is centered around where the main characters live as adults, and how inaccurately the show portrays the distance between Pittsburgh and New Jersey.

First, let's recap: the Pearsons grew up in Pittsburgh, and none of the family members live there as adults. Kate and Toby live in Los Angeles, Kevin formerly lived in LA (where he worked on The Manny) and currently lives in New York City, Randall and Beth live in New Jersey, and it seems like Rebecca and Miguel live in either New Jersey or upstate New York. They frequently show up at Randall's house for Thanksgiving and other family events.

The head-scratching issue — pointed out by a San Francisco moms blog — is how quickly the characters sometimes travel from Pittsburgh to New Jersey, which are actually six hours apart. In the "Super Bowl Sunday" episode, we learn that each of the Big Three deals with the anniversary of Jack's death in different ways, and Kevin ends up at the special tree (presumably in Pittsburgh) where the family scattered his dad's ashes. He has a heartfelt "talk" with Jack and then calls Rebecca, who's practicing her tradition of making lasagna and watching the big game by herself at home. But then, a few frames later, Kevin is on the couch with Rebecca, and they're watching the game together.


Similarly, in season two's "Number One" episode, which chronicles Kevin's journey from injured football star to grieving adult with a painkiller addiction, we see adult Kevin return to his high school in Pittsburgh to give a speech. After he has a terrible night and hooks up with a former classmate, he flees to the one place he knows he can find help: Randall's house. The only problem is this all seems to occur while it's still dark out during the same night.

Have you noticed this too?! Redditors have taken note of the discrepancy as well, and they're torn between calling it a plot hole and assuming that Kevin has enough money to charter a plane (not sure about that theory). At the end of the day, who are we kidding? A detail this small would never deter us from loving every single episode of This Is Us.

Image Source: NBC
From Our Partners
Sterling K. Brown and Ron Cephas Jones at the 2018 Emmys
This Is Us Cast at the 2018 Emmys
Hopeful This Is Us Quotes
Milo Ventimiglia Talks Saddest Scenes on This Is Us
Sad Songs on This Is Us
This Is Us Season 2 Finale Recap
This Is Us Season 3 Theories
This Is Us Season 3 Pictures
The Story Behind Jack's Mustache on This Is Us
This Is Us Season 3 Cast
Who Plays Jack's Brother Nicky on This Is Us?
This Is Us Season 3 Details
From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds