Any dedicated fan of The Bachelor and The Bachelorette knows Jimmy "Rose-tradamus" Kimmel is practically a wizard when it comes to predicting the "winner" of every season. With a little (OK, probably a lot) of help from his wife, the talk-show host accurately speculated that Hannah Brown would choose Jed Wyatt, Colton Underwood would pick Cassie Randolph, Becca Kufrin would end up with Garrett Yrigoyen, and the list of correct guesses goes on and on. Naturally, he had to share his thoughts on who'll earn Peter Weber's coveted final rose after the pilot's season premiered Monday night, and honestly, I'm not too sold on his selection.
After Kimmel and guest star Tiffany Haddish hilariously grilled Weber about his Harry Potter-esque forehead scar and why he still lives with his parents, Kimmel revealed his top three picks: Hannah Ann, the first-impression-rose recipient; Madison, who nabbed the first one-on-one date; and Kelley, the attorney he met in a hotel a month before his season began filming. I don't want to entirely spoil the video, but I will say Kimmel's final pick has a pretty annoying penchant for interrupting other contestants despite her sweet demeanor, so it'll likely stir up some debate among Bachelor Nation. Watch the entire segment above to see Pilot Pete try to maintain a poker face while Kimmel broadcasts his prediction.