Reminder: The 9 Shocking Pieces of Information That Were Left Out of Making a Murderer

While Making a Murderer definitely mentions Avery's early crime in the first episode, the details of the incident are a lot more grisly than what's portrayed. Steven describes "playing" with the cat and tossing it over the fire. Yet, according to an article by Madison.com, "he poured gas and oil on a cat, threw it in a bonfire and watched it die."