Everything You Must Know Before Supernatural Season 12 Premieres

While the season finale left Sam's fate — at the end of Men of Letters member Lady Toni's gun barrel, mind you — ambiguous, Jared Padalecki recently confirmed our deepest fears. "She shot him," Padalecki revealed in a brief chat with TVLine. "I don't know where, but I know she shot him . . . What else is new, Sam gets injured! At least I'm not getting tortured, yet."