We obviously have to talk about Hal. Though he doesn't do anything particularly suspicious on the night of the show, he's always been a top suspect when it comes to the Black Hood. Hal has been a popular choice from the start, mostly because he has such a strong likeness to the man who shoots Fred Andrews at the end of season one.
When it comes to motive, it's a bit harder to pin down why Hal of all people would be doing this. But, hey, maybe that whole Chic thing really got under his skin. We're leaving him on the list for now.
