When it came time for Colton to face the women he let go, it was obvious that there was tension. Tayshia parted with a graciousness that fans had to commend her for, especially considering she just had to watch their breakup on the big screen. Colton told Tayshia that he had too much respect for her to be "half in," and she accepted that explanation. She told Colton that she hoped he would find happiness and thanked him for opening her up to finding new love.
Hannah, however, was still very hurt over their breakup, revealing to Chris that she felt blindsided by the entire thing, especially since Colton gave her the first-impression rose and continually told her she "felt like home." She asked Colton why he didn't even try to go on the overnight date with her, a question Chris echoed, asking why he hadn't even given it a shot. "How I was feeling in another relationship at that time was stronger," Colton responded.
"And that sounds brutal, but you deserve the honesty. In that moment [he decided to chase Cassie], the show was over. I was 100 percent hers, and I couldn't do anything about it."
In the end, Hannah told Colton that she thinks he's a good guy and she wants nothing but happiness for him.
