Popsugar Living Halloween How to Make Spider Peanut Butter Cookies The Halloween Dessert Every Reese's Fan Should Make October 24, 2017 by Anna Monette Roberts First Published: August 20, 2015 View On One Page Photo 3 of 6 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 3 Pull Together Your Decorating Supplies Next, you'll need a few items to create the legs and eyeballs of the spiders: White icing for the eyeballs Multicolored nonpareils for the eyeballs Melted dark chocolate for the legs Wooden skewers or toothpicks to "paint" the dark chocolate Previous Next Start Slideshow HalloweenRecipesBack To SchoolCookiesBakingBreaking NewsPeanut ButterBack To School FoodFall FoodCooking How-To