Skip Nav
Halloween Costumes 2018
These Easy Thomas the Tank Engine Halloween Costumes Will Make Kids Scream "All Aboard!"
Halloween Merchandise Is Popping Up All Over Disneyland, and We'll Take It All, Please
Take Me to Your Leader, Target! These Halloween Drinking Glasses Are Perfection
Gifts For Women
The Best Gifts For Moms Whose Favorite Word Is the F-Word
Home Shopping
Parents Can't Get Enough of These Cozy Bean Bags That Turn Into Full-Size Beds

Why I'm Afraid of Becoming a Mother-in-Law

I Want a Daughter Because I'm Scared of Being a Second-String Mother-in-Law

Future Perpetual Mother-In-Law?

Let me start off by saying that I really just want a third child, period. Boy or girl, I'd be happy with either . . . but if I'm being honest, I'd be really, really excited if it was a girl. It's not because I'm dying for more estrogen in a house that has far too many penises, because I'm envisioning mani and pedi bonding dates, or because I'm lusting after the baby girl dress aisle. No. I want to have a daughter because, right now, I'm staring straight down the barrel of mother-in-law status for life. Could it be in the cards that I'm cast out of the very family I helped create? The answer is yes.

I know, I know . . . it's so cliche, and you're probably rolling your eyes, but there are legit reasons why I'm scared. Mainly, science. Google "mother-in-law relationships" and actual studies will show how there's a biological explanation for why, on average, mother-in-laws who don't have daughters tend to have a harder time with family relations than others. But data aside, I have my real life to also make me wary.

What if I'm not afforded the opportunity to be close to my grandkids simply because I had sons?

Growing up, my grandma on my mom's side was a queen in my eyes. No one could compare, especially my dad's mom. Not because she wasn't great as well, but she and my mom didn't have a close relationship, so our relationship was never going to get to the point of intimacy that my relationship with my mom's mom was. And now that I'm a mom, I see it playing out again.

When I had my kids, the first person I wanted to see was my own mom, and she helped care for both of my sons immediately following their births. I wouldn't have even thought to ask my husband if he wanted to see his mom right away, even though, technically, they're just as much his children. My mother-in-law also lives in England, so that's a contributing factor, but let's be real . . . the mom (typically) rules the roost, and I don't know any of my friends who opted for their mother-in-laws to come help with their babies ahead of their own moms. The mother-daughter relationship is arguably deeper (albeit more complicated) than a mother-son bond, and a part of me gets sad that I may never get to experience that connection. Even the terrifying teenage daughter years. I say bring it on.

You know the saying, "A son is a son until he takes a wife, but a daughter is a daughter all her life"? In my mother-in-law's case, one of her sons left London to live in America with a woman. It's only now that I have two sons of my own that I try to imagine myself in her shoes. It can't be easy to have your son live so far away, start a family, and not have a super close relationship with his wife. As a result of all of the aforementioned — but mainly literal distance — my kids don't end up seeing their paternal grandparents as much as they should. I imagine this exact scenario could also be in my cards.

I know I probably sound like a crazy person even thinking about this, especially since my kids are 4 and not even 2. But they're the loves of my life, and if the fates allow, I'll be a grandma one day. But what if I'm not afforded the opportunity to be close to my grandkids simply because I had sons? It's an inkling of a thought that remains tucked in the back of my mind. And with that, Operation Try For Number Three (but let it be a girl) lives another day.

Image Source: Patrice Poltzer
From Our Partners
Can Stress Make PCOS Worse?
Why Miranda Bailey Is the Best Grey's Anatomy Character
Easy Ways to Calm Kids Down
Morning Routine For 3-Year-Old
Parenting a Strong-Willed Child
Morning Routine With 8-Month-Old Baby
I'm a Special Needs Mom, and I Hate Birthday Parties
How to Wear Dresses For Fall 2018
Divorce Lawyer Shares Marriage Advice
What It's Like to Be a Latina Journalist
Why It's My Responsibility to Mentor Other Latinas
I Refuse to Be My Daughter's Friend
From Our Partners
Latest Moms
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds