Last year we tried everything peppermint that we could get our hands on to separate the naughty from the nice, so you wouldn't have to waste your time (or money) on the merely so-so. This year, we're doing the same with everything pumpkin spice. From crackers to Pop-Tarts to ice cream to cider, we present all the pumpkin spice edibles we've tracked down, ranked from low to high.
— Additional reporting by Nicole Perry
Photos: Anna Monette Roberts and Nicole Perry