Never in taste test history has a group been so divided. Half the group gave the pint a perfect five, and half, a loathsome one. Tasters felt surprised by the extremely obvious raspberry jam flavor. But many announced fruit in ice cream ain't their thang, and they struggled with the fruitiness.
Some wanted more raspberry core, and others wanted to forgo it. A taster who gave the pint a one-star review compared it to "Smuckers with ice cream" and added, "No way." Another who prized the pint with "5++" stars said, "I could eat this morning, noon, and night! So good!"