Barney Stinson Gives Sophie Major Advice in the "HIMYF" Midseason Finale

John Corbett plays Robert, a chef who Sophie meets at a luxe event while supporting Valentina. They connect when he finds Sophie in her underwear in a supply closet, having given her dress to Valentina amid a fashion emergency. They date through episode 11, when Sophie becomes worried Robert might actually be her father. Her mom and Robert both confirm he isn't, but she's too freaked out by it to keep seeing him. Thankfully Corbett fanatics can get more of the actor in "And Just Like That" season two and "XO, Kitty."