One particularly memorable wing of Cassie's wasn't technically worn IRL; it appeared in Nate's fantasy in episode two. To achieve that double wing punctuated by glitter, Davy relied on the faithful Urban Decay Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliner ($21).
Some might argue that Cassie's extensive morning routine is her character's most unforgettable moment this season, but let's not forget what happens after that routine is completed. In an attempt to get Nate's attention, Cassie spends the majority of episode three trying on a range of winged eyeliners — many of which were loosely inspired by other characters on the show. While he ignored her nine times out of 10, he finally gave her a second glance after she tried a white rhinestone-encrusted cat-eye.
For this look, Davy re-created an iconic Maddy look from the first season for Cassie. "I inverted [the carnival look], so instead of a dark wing, it was white, and I made it thicker and longer so it would have that visibility [for Nate]," Davy said. "I wanted her to look great, but also jarring and borderline ridiculous." Unfortunately, Davy has yet to cosign a go-to product for this one (she used at least three different formulas to make it work). "Long story short, I haven't found my killer white eyeliner," Davy says. "Something for me to think about for the future with Half Magic."
